FROLITICKS

Satirical commentary on Canadian and American current political issues

Canada’s Major Concern is Less to do with Fentanyl Importation than with Guns

Ontario being Canada’s most populous province, according to its provincial government, 91 percent of handguns recovered from crimes in 2024 came in illegally from the United States.  It should be noted that the actual figures are almost certainly higher because many recovered guns have been tampered with to make them untraceable.  According to the Canada Border Services Agency, Canadian authorities have also been confiscating more firearms at the border with the U.S.: 827 in 2024, up from 459 in 2020. The same situation can be said for Mexico where since October 2024, the Mexican authorities had seized 18,000 firearms, of which nearly 80 percent came from the U.S.

In addition, there is the accompanying illegal importation of ammunition to both countries, much again originating in the U.S.  Just recently, it was reported by Mexico’s Defense Secretary, Gen. Ricardo Trevilla Trejo, that about 137,000 .50-caliber rounds had been seized since 2012.  Of those, 47 percent came from the Lake City Army Ammunition Plant, which is the largest manufacturer of rifle rounds used by the American military — some which were sold commercially in gun shops in the southern states.  According to documents obtained by reporters, many of these rounds ended up in the hands of Mexican cartel members, who have used them to terrorize civilians and security forces alike.  Armed with .50-caliber firearms, cartel gunmen have downed helicopters, assassinated government officials, shot at police and military forces, and killed civilians.

Demand for illegal firearms in Canada is driving the smuggling from the U.S., especially for handguns used in most violent crimes.  In 2023, Canada further tightened control over handguns, making them virtually impossible to buy or transfer legally.  Despite the stricter gun control measures in Canada, the easy legal access to guns in the U.S. remains an issue.  Once obtained by gun smugglers, the profits to be made are high given that a handgun for example can be obtained illegally in Canada for three to four times the original purchase.  Gun violence has also gone up significantly across Canada.  According to government data, the homicide rate increased 33 percent from 2013 to 2023, largely because of firearm killings which jumped 89 percent.  While firearms and stabbings alternated as the leading cause of homicides in the past, firearms have been the primary method of killing in Canada every year since 2016.

When compared to use by Canadians of fentanyl, the difference is the fact that the vast majority of fentanyl is manufactured within Canada for sale in the Canadian market.  As a result, although still serious, the export or import of the illicit drug is less of an issue for Canadian authorities.  However, fentanyl and other illegal drugs are being provided by drug gangs within the country, many of whom obtain firearms for protection and threats vis-à-vis other rival gangs.  Quite often, when Canadian authorities arrest members of such gangs, the firearms seized are guns smuggled in from the U.S, with some altered to fire automatically.

In conclusion, when it comes to U.S.-Canada-Mexico security discussions, the continuing concern over related gun and ammunition smuggling out of the U.S. has to be on the table.  One recognizes that the American authorities have attempted to coordinate initiatives to deal with this issue, but much more needs to be done.  Perhaps, President Trump could give some real thought to this serious matter, as Canadian and Mexican lives are at stake.


 

Leave a comment »

Prohibited ‘Assault-Style’ Weapons Have No Place in Canadian Society

On December 6, 1989, a man entered a mechanical engineering classroom at Montreal’s École Polytechnique armed with a semi-automatic weapon.  After separating the women from the men, he opened fire on the women while screaming, “You are all feminists.”  Fourteen young women were murdered, and 13 other people were seriously wounded.  The shooter then turned the gun on himself.  After the events of that tragic December, the Coalition for Gun Control was formed in Canada.  Their efforts contributed to the 1995 adoption of Bill C-68, the federal firearm control legislation.  Its stipulations included mandatory registration of all firearms and licensing for firearm owners; a national registry for all weapons; background checks; and verification processes and controls on ammunition sales.

On April 18–19, 2020, a gunman committed multiple shootings in the province of Nova Scotia, killing 22 people and injuring three others before he was shot and killed by the Royal Canadian Mounted Police (RCMP).  Two assault-style weapons were used in shootings, although it appears that they were not legally acquired and the gunman was known to police.  Subsequently and effective immediately in May 2020, the federal government introduced legislation to ban a total of 1,500 assault-style firearms for use, sale, import or transport in Canada.  It includes a two-year amnesty period for current owners.  Eventually, there will also be a buyback program, but those details were still being worked out.

This September, in an obvious political move, the provincial government of Alberta announced steps to oppose federal firearms prohibition legislation and the potential seizure of thousands of assault-style weapons.  It intends to ask the RCMP not to take part in the confiscation of these weapons.  Alberta’s chief firearms officer proclaimed: “The planned confiscations represent a fatal approach to reducing violence in Canadian society and are unwarranted and unacceptable infringements on the property rights and personal freedoms of Albertans.”

A survey, conducted in May 2020 exclusively for Global News, found that 52 percent of Canadians polled, living in nine major centres, agree that all types of guns should be made illegal.  The polling was completed between March 24 and April 2, before the above noted mass shooting happened in Nova Scotia.  The poll by the Angus-Reid Institute showed about 80 percent of Canadians also support a ban on “assault weapons.”  Canada is not the only country to ban assault-style weapons.  In March 2019, New Zealand banned all military-style semi-automatic weapons and assault rifles after a deadly shooting killed more than 50 people. 

Interestingly, there is no constitutional right to bear arms as in the U.S.  Indeed, one can Make a case that it is a weak argument in Canada that the banning of such weapons is an infringement on someone’s rights and personal freedoms.  I would argue that, just as owning and driving a motor vehicle, owning a gun is a privilege requiring training in its use, registration and other prescribed requirements for licensed users as regulated by law.  Just as there are restrictions on the ownership and use of a motor vehicle and one’s driving license, so must there be restrictions on acquiring certain types of guns as a matter of public safety.  No one should be surprised that after the Nova Scotia shootings some sort of inevitable government gun control action would occur, especially as the vast majority of Canadians appear to be in support of such initiatives.  During the 2019 federal election campaign Prime Minister Justin Trudeau noted that: “These weapons were designed for one purpose and one purpose only: to kill the largest number of people in the shortest amount of time”.

Although I do not own a gun, like many Canadians I believe strongly that the possession of either handguns or military-style semi-automatic weapons is not a fundamental right.  The fewer these weapons are around and accessible, the better off and safer we will all be.  One only has to look at the American tragic situation involving an increasing number of mass shootings using assault-style weapons every year, including those in schools, malls and workplaces.  Canada should do everything possible to avoid going down the same road!

Leave a comment »

When It Comes To Violent Crime In North America, All Is Not Well

The recent mass shootings in Buffalo, New York and Uvalde, Texas, and multiple shootings across the U.S. this past month, have once again raised the anger of Americans on both sides of the political spectrum.  The Democrats are being attacked by Republicans for being soft on crime and the Republicans are being accused of blocking proposed measures to restrict the sale and ownership of guns.  In Canada, the federal government has introduced legislation to further restrict access to handguns, including stopping the illegal trafficking of guns across the border with the U.S.  As recent polls have indicated, there is little doubt that Americans are feeling increasingly less safe.  With an increase in gun violence in some of Canada’s largest cities, Canadians are not far behind in their perception of growing violent crime.

The fact of the matter is that the issue of violent crime, like other social-economic issues, is a divisive one no matter how you look at it.  Conservatives will accuse liberals of letting criminals off the hook, while liberals will declare that conservatives have no other policy than putting everyone in prisons and increasing police powers.  Police shootings have also garnered the attention of both political groups, especially in the U.S.  Now, there is at least a belief that the police have to find better ways to deal with persons with mental health conditions and members of minority groups, incorporating social and health services available in the community.  There is also a need to deal differently with drugs and drug addicts, recognizing that addiction is a health issue and should be dealt with accordingly, especially in light of the current epidemic of overdoses in both countries.

Radicalization of youth, especially young men, has increasingly become a source of violent behaviour, often associated with hate crimes.  More needs to be done to deal with the spread of hate literature, disinformation and conspiracy theories over social media.  Surely, both conservatives and liberals can agree that more education has to be available and supported to prevent such influences.  The current division of beliefs and values based on racial, ethnic, religious and sexual orientation has to be dealt with in no uncertain terms.  The situation is eating away at the very core of our democratic societies.

There are no easy solutions to dealing with violent crime as a social issue.  Many factors have to be considered, including socio-economic matters.  Unemployment is a major one, wherein people are prevented from making a living wage and securing affordable housing.  Increased opportunities for an education aimed at preparing people to enter the labour market with applicable skills and attributes is another issue.  Communities need to be encouraged and supported in order to develop local initiatives aimed at reducing criminal activities.  Improvements have to be made to increase timely access to mental health and social services at the community level.  Localized addiction programs have to be improved, with the aim of tackling drug problems and preventing their associated health issues and fatalities.

Whether taking a hard-line approach or preferring a more progressive approach, neither alone offers one-size-fits-all solutions.  A multi-approach strategy is what is required, and political sloganeering is not going to do anyone any good.  Simply de-funding the police in support of promoting social measures is not the answer.  Retraining and re-educating the police in how to better deal with such issues as domestic violence, racism and mental disabilities would appear to be a much better idea.  In Canada, several municipal mayors have called on the federal government to ban the possession of handguns.  However, despite Canada’s already strict handgun control measures, there continues to be violent crimes committed with the use of illegal or stolen handguns.  Members of drug gangs and radical factions have little problems in accessing such weapons.  One day our prisons will be overflowing with their convicted felons.

Until we deal with the underlying socio-economic factors in both countries, one can only conclude that we will see increased waves of violent crime.  This outcome doesn’t depend on whether you have conservative or liberal governments.

Leave a comment »

The Tragedy of Gun Violence in Canada is One of Our Own Doing

Back in 2018, a random mass shooting that killed a 10-year-old girl and an 18-year-old woman in Toronto, Ontario, brought about another call by gun control advocates and some politicians for increased controls on guns, and in particular handguns.  According to Statistics Canada reports, “firearm-related violent crime” has gone up 42 per cent since 2013.  However, like in the U.S., these statistics include the fact that the most common way Canadians die from firearms is by suicide, be it by handguns or standard rifles and shotguns.  Unlike in the U.S., ownership of handguns in Canada comes with several restrictions and requirements because most handguns that are not prohibited are restricted and must be registered.  Being restricted, the permitted purposes for handgun ownership are for target practice or target shooting competitions and as part of a collection.  Unlike in many U.S. states, the federal Criminal Code prohibits carrying a concealed weapon in Canada unless authorized for a lawful occupational purpose under the Firearms Act.

When it comes to handguns in particular, most violent crimes are being committed by gangs, often against other gang members.  Obviously, given Canada’s gun laws and prohibitions, the guns being used were obtained illegally.  So where do these gang members get their guns? The federal union representing the Royal Canadian Mounted Police (RCMP) and some police chiefs have themselves opposed a complete gun ban, saying it does little to address gang violence and gun smuggling at the Canada-U.S. border, which accounts for the majority of firearm-related violence.  In one example, they refer to the case of a Michigan man who in 2017 admitted to reselling 67 guns on Toronto’s black market.  However, while most of illegal handguns are smuggled in, many are also purchased legally in Canada and then resold illegally, what’s known as “straw purchasing”.  In addition, they rightfully believe that most guns used in violent crimes are obtained illegally, so it doesn’t make sense to ban something that’s already prohibited.

In truth, of illegal handguns that can be successfully traced by the RCMP (which can be as little as one third), about half have been found to start out as legal guns purchased at a Canadian gun store — with the other definitively coming by way of American gun smugglers.  In 2016 the RCMP was estimating that up to 61 per cent of illegal guns started life as a legal Canadian firearm.  Recognizing this fact, recently the federal government modestly expanded a number of existing laws, like lengthened prison sentences for people who smuggle firearms or who manipulate gun magazines beyond their legal limit.  Changes to “red flag” laws grant expanded powers to courts to search and seize the possessions of gun owners.

The Canadian government recognizes that lawful gun owners are not a threat, and have thus taken a cautious approach to enacting more forceful gun laws.  As it is now, gun laws already provide sufficient regulation of handgun ownership and use.  The real problem is how to reduce the availability of illegal handguns which are increasingly being used for the purposes of crime.  To do so will require the provision of adequate resources to national and local law enforcement to effectively go after the smugglers and illegal gun sellers.  This enforcement has to take place at the borders and by local guns and gangs units that now exist in every major city.  For society at large, the real fundamental issues are social and economic in nature.  The actual question is why people are using guns to commit crimes in the first place?  This is a Canadian problem, and we have only ourselves to resolve it.

Leave a comment »