Recently, I read a number of articles in reputable sources blaming governments for all kinds of things. The complaints ranged from the decline in North American manufacturing jobs to proactive policies aimed at dealing with climate change and poverty. The problem appears to be that the authors really don’t understand just what impact government policies and programs can have in reality. Indeed, what is the ultimate role and purpose of governing?
Let’s put it in simpler terms. Governments are needed to ensure peace and good order in a society. They do this by creating laws, administering and enforcing them for the good of all citizens. Governments also strive to protect the individual rights of their citizens, constitutional or otherwise. However, unlike a century ago, societal needs have become more complex and are influenced by many other factors — from new technologies, globalization, ideologies, oligopolies, world and domestic economic institutions, the environment, etc., etc. Most of these factors are outside the direct influence or control of governments. If anything, the impact of other factors is felt more than that of government initiatives which tend to be more reactive than proactive.
Today, hundreds of lobbyists continuously work to influence government policies, often through financial support for politicians and parties. While governments attempt to be perceived as being independent, the reality is that the most influential interest groups get their fullest attention. For example, one only has to look at recent tax reform initiatives in the U.S. and the influence of the National Rifle Association regarding the current gun control debate. Large business organizations run the economy, not government. President Trump is witnessing their significant influence in the current debate over free trade versus his administration’s move to increased protectionism.
Except in the case of wars, governments rarely tackle issues in a speedy and drastic way, but rather do things in a deliberately slow and incremental approach. Sometimes, politicians just want to please as many interest groups as possible so as to get re-elected in the short-term. It’s rare that governments attempt to move quickly to tackle those longer-term issues for fear of alienating their supporters, most of whom can’t see further than the end of their noses. Unfortunately, rightly or wrongly, critics ignore the realities of governing today’s complex societies. Many of the issues we face today have emerged and evolved over decades of governments with varying political stripes. In order to be re-elected, political parties are more or less forced to take “centrist” positions or face the countervailing influence of powerful interest groups. It’s hard to govern effectively and with a longer-term perspective when the immediate primary objective is political survival. Sorry to be so cynical, but it’s been a tough week!