Well, here we go again! The U.S. federal government is shut down once again, leaving hundreds of thousands of Americans without access to government services across the country and thousands of civil servants without pay. It all seems rather incredulous! Congress couldn’t agree on a budget needed to keep the government running. As in the past, Washington politics is playing its usual role. Too often, non-budget related policies are tied into budgetary proceedings, with both federal parties attempting to coerce the other party to support certain political positions.
One could not see this happening in Canada which operates under a parliamentary system. Every year, the Government tables a budget for the following year which is then reviewed in advance by a finance committee in both the House of Commons and the Senate. Now, the passage of budget bills is considered as a ‘vote of confidence’ in Parliament for the ruling party. Majority governments normally have little problem passing budgets between elections. However, in the case of minority governments, failure to secure sufficient votes from the opposition parties will lead to the dissolution of Parliament. If the opposition parties can agree, they could subsequently form a coalition government. If not, an election has to be called. In the interim, the government continues to operate until a new ruling government is formed post-election. Most importantly, the budgetary process is carried out in an atmosphere of decorum based on past conventions.
The American process on the other hand is carried out with a great deal of incivility by both parties, and in today’s climate by the President. Attempting to garner public support for their position, Congressional parties and the President are blaming the other side for the shut down. Instead of debating matters in Congress, both sides argue their positions in the main and social media. The entire process becomes an unruly mess. What’s worst, Senators and House Representatives continue to be paid, while government workers have to wait to be paid once the shut down is over. Several social, health and environmental protection services are affected during the duration of any shut down. Examples of such services are too many to list here. Unlike under Canada’s parliamentary system, there do not appear to be any real consequences for the governing party in Congress — each vying for political points. Maybe, it’s time to take a non-partisan look at the current budgetary processes. Otherwise, the American public will have to again endure future government shut downs.